Foreign experience of legal regulation of criminal liability for violation of the procedure for transplantation of human anatomical materials established by law

Home/2024, Vol. 12, No. 1/Foreign experience of legal regulation of criminal liability for violation of the procedure for transplantation of human anatomical materials established by law

Cell and Organ Transplantology. 2024; 12(1):22-27
DOI: 10.22494/cot.v12i1.162

Foreign experience of legal regulation of criminal liability for violation of the procedure for transplantation of human anatomical materials established by law

Tkach Yu.

  • Dnipro State University of Internal Affairs, Dnipro, Ukraine

Abstract

The article examines the experience of individual countries in matters of legal regulation of criminal liability for violation of the procedure for transplantation of human anatomical materials in order to determine important legal assets of foreign legislation, which could be discussed for the purpose of further implementation in Ukrainian legislation.
Within the framework of the article, we will analyze national and international legislation, namely, we will compare the content of Articles 143 and 144 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine with the content of the corresponding articles and provisions in the legislation of several countries from the perspective of the used terminology, interpretation of concepts, descriptions of crimes, measures of criminal liability, etc.
The Constitution of Ukraine guarantees every person the right to life. However, experts increasingly raise questions about various violations of this right from the perspective of transplantation of human anatomical materials. Today, criminal offenses in relation to both donors and recipients become difficult to detect due to high self-interest and profitability, disguised nature, network systematicity, extensive illegal infrastructure and fast mechanisms for its recovery, group organization and strong connections with other criminal groups, use of deception, coercion, intimidation and other methods of forced donation, corruption in the field of donation, large-scale latent level of crimes related to transplantation.
Detection of illegal transplantation is also burdened by their contradictory geography, when potential donors are recruited in the so-called “depressed” countries around the world, and anatomical materials are seized in countries that are highly developed in the field of transplantology, having loyal legislation to carry out such operations. In Ukraine, the detection of such crimes is also aggravated by the fact that people who are ready to illegally donate their organs for payment, travel to remove the organ outside the country and carry out their plans in other countries (“transplant tourism”).
Due to the low level of information and enlightenment of the society in matters of transplantation, the detection of crimes in this area is also complicated by the so-called “victimhood” of people (both donors and recipients) – a set of personal traits that cause a high probability of becoming the object of a criminal attack (a tendency to become a victim of crime).
These grounds contribute to a dynamic increase in the number of violations of the law-enforced procedure for the transplantation of human anatomical materials, which constitutes a high public danger. At the same time, the legal regulation of criminal liability for such violations still has certain differences. Therefore, the study of foreign experience in matters of transplantation, the comparison of the norms of articles in the Criminal Codes of different countries, and the analysis of concepts used in normative legal documents and their interpretations help to identify gaps in Ukrainian legislation, clarify the wording, expand the range of crimes and facilitate the qualification of their composition, adaptation of the Ukrainian legal system according to European standards.

Keywords: illegal transplantation; violation of the transplantation procedure; criminal liability for illegal transplantation; legal regulation

Full Text PDF
References

  1. Lisitsyna YuO. Differentiation of liability for illegal actions regarding the transplantation of human organs and tissues under the criminal law of certain foreign countries. Problems of legal reform and development of civil society in Ukraine: Abstracts of the Third Reporting All-Ukrainian Scientific Conference of Adjuncts, Graduate Students, and Degree Candidates. Lviv: Lviv State University of Internal Affairs, 2009. P. 71-73.
  2. Hrynchak SV. Violation of the procedure for transplantation of human organs or tissues established by law: Grounds for criminal liability: Thesis: 12.00.08. Yaroslav Mudryi National Law Academy of Ukraine. Kharkiv, 2006. 218 p.
  3. Lisitsyna YuO. Violation of the procedure for transplantation of human organs or tissues established by law and forced donation: Criminal law and criminological characteristics: Thesis: 12.00.08. Lviv State University of Internal Affairs. Lviv, 2016. 273 p.
  4. Myslyva OO. Criminal and legal characteristics and prevention of illegal activities in the field of transplantation: Monograph. Dnipro. 2020. 247 p.
  5. Musiienko AV. Prevention of crimes in the field of transplantation of human organs and tissues: Thesis for the degree of Candidate of Law: Specialty 12.00.08 “Criminal law and criminology; Criminal executive law”. Kyiv, 2010. 22 p.
  6. Chebotariova HV. Criminal and legal problems of transplantation of human organs or tissues and blood donation: Thesis: 12.00.08. Institute of State and Law of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. Kyiv, 2003. 219 p.
  7. Criminal Code of Ukraine. Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (VVR). 2001; 25-26:131. Available from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14#Text
  8. Draft of the new Criminal Code of Ukraine. Available from: https://newcriminalcode.org.ua/upload/media/2021/08/12/1-kontrolnyj-tekst-proektu-kk-25-07-2021-1.pdf
  9. Declaration on Human Organ Transplantation, adopted by the 39th World Medical Assembly. Madrid, Spain, October 1987. Available from: https://zakononline.com.ua/documents/show/157774___157774
  10. Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine. Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine. Oviedo, April 4, 1997. Available from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/994_334#Text
  11. Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine concerning Transplantation of Organs and Tissues of Human Origin (Strasbourg, 24.I.2002). Available from: https://rm.coe.int/1680081562
  12. Gesetze und Richtlinien regeln die Organ- und Gewebespende. Available from: https://www.organspende-info.de/gesetzliche-grundlagen/gesetze-und-richtlinien/
  13. Human Organ Transplants Act 1989. Available from: http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1989/ukpga_19890031_en_1
  14. Briukhovetska M. Postmortem Donation in the Legislation of Foreign Countries: Positive Experience of Law Enforcement. National law journal: theory and practice. 2016. P. 90-93.
  15. Criminal Law of the Republic of Latvia on 17.06.1998. Available from: https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/88966-the-criminal-lawThe
  16. Inimgeeniuuringute seadus Vastu võetud 13.12.2000. Available from: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/72581
  17. Criminal Code of Georgia. Available from: https://jurkniga.ua/contents/kriminalniy-kodeks-gruzii.pdf
  18. Code pénal République française Dernière mise à jour des données de ce code : 21 février 2024. Available from: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/section_lc/LEGITEXT000006070719/LEGISCTA000006089684/#LEGISCTA000006089684
  19. Myslyva OO. Criminal and legal characteristics and prevention of illegal activities in the field of transplantation: Monograph. Dnipro: Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs, 2019. 220 p.
  20. Ancel M. Utilité et méthodes du droit comparé. Eléments d’introduction générale à l’étude comparative des droits. Available from: https://www.persee.fr/doc/ridc_0035-3337_1971_num_23_4_16125
  21. Lisitsyna YuO. National factors (determinants) of criminal activity in the field of transplantation of human organs or tissues, blood donation. Legal Reform in Modern Conditions: Achievements and Prospects: Proceedings of the VI International Scientific and Practical Conference (Kyiv, National Aviation University, February 26, 2016. Vol. 1. Ternopil: Vector, 2016. 384 p.
  22. On the use of transplantation of anatomical materials to humans: Law of Ukraine dated May 17, 2018, No. 2427-VIII: as of January 7, 2022. Available from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2427-19#Text

How to cite

Tkach Yu. Foreign experience of legal regulation of criminal liability for violation of the procedure for transplantation of human anatomical materials established by law. Cell Organ Transpl. 2024; 12(1):22-27. Available from: https://doi.org/10.22494/cot.v12i1.162

 

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.